Tuesday, November 23, 2010

The Kite Runner

Perhaps it is time to present another important aspect of writing: believability. How much suspension of disbelief can an author require before a story falls apart? This can be very well demonstrated by The Kite Runner, Khaled Hosseini’s historical fiction novel. It tells the story of Amir, beginning with his life in Afghanistan with his servant and friend Hassan. Although he moves on from this life in many ways after his departure from the country of his birth and his marriage, the memory of Hassan never quite leaves him, a fact which becomes clear when he goes to meet an old friend of his father’s. But I am not here to discuss the plot of the book; I am here to discuss what, in this story, stretches my own suspension of disbelief.

In a previous essay (On the Nature of Being Qfwfq), I mentioned that character flaws are an important part of every story; that they are, at least in part, what makes a story readable. The Kite Runner’s Amir certainly has flaws, because the main character of a book is required not to be flat and boring. However, consider his friend and servant Hassan. There is something slightly odd about him as a character, which may not be obvious at first, but think: when does Hassan show that he is not “perfect”? He always takes the blame for things Amir has done, he never seems to get angry, he offers Amir endless encouragement and defends him when it becomes necessary. For example:
“...he never told on me. Never told that the mirror, like shooting walnuts at the neighbor’s dog, was always my idea.” (4)
“If he felt the sting of my tease, his smiling face didn’t show it.” (28)
“That was another thing about Hassan. He always knew when to say the right thing...” (37)
“Hassan held the slingshot pointed directly at Assef’s face. His hand trembled with the strain of the pulled elastic band and beads of sweat had erupted on his brow.” (42)
The last example is, perhaps, the most telling. Hassan is willing to defend Amir despite the fact that, as a Hazara, he is in more danger from Assef than Amir is. He is also quite obviously afraid of Assef, but he doesn’t allow that to stop him. All of this, as well as the later events that eventually cause Hassan to leave, make it clear that he is almost uncannily perfect; his arsenal of positive traits appears to have no end. This comes up again in Rahim Khan’s account of his reunion with Hassan: when first confronted with the idea of leaving, Hassan “said the village was his home now; he and Farzana had made a life for themselves there.” (206) But after Rahim Khan had spent a night in their house, Hassan informs him that they have decided to drop everything and go to Kabul to help him take care of the house. He gives no explanation, and nothing specific seems to trigger this change of mind--it’s simply another example of his lack of flaws. All in all, Hassan is not a very convincing character, simply by virtue of his virtues. This is not to say that it is impossible to have a believably selfless character, but Hassan isn’t it.

There is also an interesting correlation which I think may be more than just a coincidence. Near the beginning of the book, when Assef harasses Amir and Hassan, Hassan’s threat is as follows:
“‘...If you make a move, they’ll have to change your nickname from Assef “the Ear Eater” to “One-Eyed Assef,” because I have this rock pointed at your left eye.’” (42)
One might be a little confused by the decision to be specific about which eye, because it doesn’t seem to be an important distinction--at least, not until Amir again meets Assef.  Amir has come to retrieve Sohrab, and Assef forces Amir to fight him. Sohrab proceeds to defend Amir with his slingshot:
“Then Assef was screaming. He put his hand where his left eye had been just a moment ago.” (291)
Again, it doesn’t seem like much at first, just a bit of helpful detail. But when you examine the two statements together, you notice that in both cases it is the left eye that is threatened. Now, consider the fact that Sohrab is Hassan’s son, and that Hassan, from what we know of him, would probably have done the same thing to protect Amir if it became necessary. Besides being a reminder of Hassan’s unrealistic personality, this underlines how similar Sohrab is to his father. Take this with the fact that Sohrab is almost identical to Hassan, and you have a twist of fate that doesn’t quite ring true.

In fact, Assef seems to be a center of impossible coincidences. The most obvious of these by far is Amir’s meeting him while searching for Sohrab. Hosseini seems to realize how ridiculous this is, and makes an attempt to point it out while staying in character:
“The moment felt surreal--no, not surreal, absurd...My past was like that, always turning up...he was already here, in the flesh, sitting less than ten feet from me, after all these years.” (281)
Although this is an admirable effort to put the situation into perspective, saying that he, too, finds it difficult to believe, its real effect is to make the coincidence seem even more impossible. The way in which the revelation is structured leads the reader to wonder whether the author simply ran out of surprises; whether he constructed this scene just because he couldn’t think of another way to further the plot. A similar emphasis on unreality surrounds one of the direct results of Amir’s meeting Assef; Amir is in the hospital reflecting on his injuries:
“I kept thinking of something else Armand/Dr. Faruqi had said: The impact had cut your upper lip in two, he had said, clean down the middle. Clean down the middle. Like a harelip.” (297)
Here we have an example of an absurdity associated with Hassan, who had a harelip as well, though he was born with his. The situation seems to say that Amir has, in some sense, become Hassan--or at least, the two are now much more similar. Now, I must admit, fiction is not intended to be exactly like real life; if it were, we wouldn’t bother to read it. However, an author cannot insert something as bizarre as this and make the reader believe it. Even if it is accepted on one level, on another the reader will be thinking that maybe the situation is just a little too perfect.

The Kite Runner does not by any means fail to get its point across, mainly about the struggle to overcome one’s past and the difficulty of stopping a chain of lies once it has been started. The story itself is riveting and generally well-written. I would certainly recommend it to anyone who hasn’t read it--but be prepared for an overabundance of impossible coincidences. Be careful of scenes that fall apart when given too much thought; they can be the downfall of an otherwise good book.

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

A Follow-Up on the Justin Beiber War

You know, my original intention wasn't to prolong the argument. I just wanted people to stop fighting. Clearly, that's not going to happen. I would like to back out of this argument, but first I must clear something up.
We have the right to express our opinions about whatever we want. You might not give a damn about him but we do. Just because you don't like him and don't listen to his music, it doesn't mean that the whole world is going to stop this because what you say. quite frankly you should eat your own words because you are not being tolerant yourself were not the ones getting all crazy and angry about the opposing side disagreeing with us. --Karen Chavez, in response to my own post
I was not denying your right to express your opinion at all. On the contrary, I was saying that everyone has a right to an opinion--which is the reason we should not be arguing. I suppose I may be nullifying my point by responding to your post, but the concept is a sound one.

As for the claim that I specifically don't like Beiber, may I direct you to this statement of mine?
I don't have an opinion on Justin Beiber...but I'm not a "hater" either. I find it extremely interesting that there is no middle ground, only the fans and the "haters".
I do not dislike Beiber just because I don't listen to his music. I simply don't care one way or the other.

Now, to your third point, that I am being intolerant and "getting all crazy and angry" about others disagreeing with me. As a matter of fact, this is impossible, because I am not in direct disagreement with anyone whose post I referenced. It's all right with me if you guys disagree with each other, but why can't you respect that other people have opinions just as much as you do? Why can't you just agree to disagree?

I will not escalate this further. There is no point in attempting to provoke me. My point is to prevent an argument, not to start a new one. Go ahead and continue arguing if you want, I guess, instead of learning to be understanding of others. I can't stop you, and I will not be a part of another unnecessary argument. So I leave you with the following thought:

Isn't a war just a larger-scale argument?

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

A Mid-November Morning's Ramble

Writing interesting stuff on demand is hard. I'll bet you've encountered this at one time or another--which is why most of what goes up here is random story chunks on which I need feedback (which, by the way, I don't seem to be getting). Writing boring stuff on demand is also hard, because writing anything on demand is hard, but it's slightly easier because on-demand brain-spew is usually rather dull from the point of view of anyone but the source.

So here I sit, writing a brain-spew post on demand in the least interesting way possible.

I wonder why this is. I know plenty of people, myself included, who can bang out a decent short story in about ten minutes with the right inspiration, but blank out completely when confronted with an assignment. If I were commanded to write a completely new story right now, with no specific range of subjects, I couldn't do it--partly because most of my story ideas have to marinate in the brain a bit before they get written (with a few exceptions), and partly because my current thoughts consist of Give me some parameters, dang it!

Why can't we generate something new and brilliant when commanded to do so? Why is it that we wake up in the middle of the night with brilliant ideas, but are incapable of this when someone tells us to? (Which is only a guess, because I don't have much experience with this. Incidentally, have you noticed that I really like parentheses?)

This is what happens when you let my brain loose to spew where it may. Perhaps I ought to have warned you, but I didn't think of it until just now. Sorry.

To drag out a nothing-post even longer, isn't it interesting how our writing styles tend to mimic those of our favourite authors to a certain extent? I'm not just referring to my strewing of "u"s here (although I must ask, what do Americans have against this innocent vowel?)--after reading a particularly good book, I unconsciously alter my writing ever so slightly so that it becomes similar. This sometimes happens with particularly bad books as well, in which case there is nothing to do but reread something by Terry Pratchett, or someone else amusing (and, often, British).

I think perhaps I ought to end this ramble before it becomes large enough to devour the entire internet, or possibly just the more accessible parts.

So long, and thanks for all the fish.

Friday, November 5, 2010

An Introduction to the Encyclopaedia Fantastica

Alternate title: "Constance is Starting a Pointless Project"/"Soon Every Post Will Have a Classification"

Some of you may know that a lot of my free time is spent making up weird, random creatures, mostly in the realm of dragons but sometimes involving other species as well. Most of these creatures have enough information attached to them to fill a small book, and most of them never get a story into which I can insert this dreck. So I have decided to write an Encyclopaedia, which is like an encyclopedia, but with an extra "a" and a superior air[1].

Periodically, you will see posts which consist of a drawing (done by yours truly, and therefore probably not of much interest, but oh well) accompanied by an outline of the information found in an encyclopedia, with reference to that species. I will keep this up for as long as it takes for someone to get bored and complain.

Note: The Encyclopaedia Fantastica contains only those creatures I have conjured up to exist in this world. Those native to my imaginary world, Terre[2], are supposedly being catalogued elsewhere as soon as I get around to it.

Enjoy?


[1] And British. Look up “anglophile”, why don’t you.
[2] If you speak French, you will know that this is a total cop-out name for a world, because “terre” is French for “earth”. Hey, you try coming up with a creative name for your own planet while juggling as many imaginary countries as I do.

A Commentary on the Justin Beiber War

I think you guys will both be very lonely if you keep trying to singing Justin Bieber's songs, because if you do then (one) you will be devastated and live a pessimistic life when he dies and (two) you'll probably want to sing his songs for a living or something, but you would barely get any money and end up as a hobo on the street. ASTI probably accepted you to cure you from singing those songs all the time. You really need to rethink your life.    --Jesse Valdez

I like Justin Bieber and I don't have to change. What if you like ballet, should you stop being so attached to it because no other guy is doing ballet? Why don't you think that over?  Jesse thinks he can stop Sam and I from signing Justin Bieber. I do not think that ,that is going to work. So do please try again.
--Billy Lau

I want to respond to this post to defend all the Beiber HATERS!!!!!! yeah WOOT-WOOT! people have to understand that every celebrity has people that dis-like their signing voice and everything that may have to do with them, including and in this case it would have to be the voice. --Ivan Arreola
It appears that, throughout the school year, there has been an ongoing war about people liking Justin Beiber or not. Above you will find excerpts from those posts I have been able to unearth. I believe this can be used to demonstrate a long-standing concern of mine--so you Beiber-soldiers listen, and listen well.

For myself, I don't have an opinion on Justin Beiber. I have never listened to his music, mainly because I find that most contemporary teenage music is...well, I don't care for it. Obviously, this keeps me miles away from the class of "Beiber fangirl", but I'm not a "hater" either. I find it extremely interesting that there is no middle ground, only the fans and the "haters". I think this says a lot about our society, actually--but more on that in another post.

Each side in this Beiber-war seems to be trying to make themselves seem right, to subjugate the other side's opinions. Jesse says that fans of Justin Beiber will end up as hobos and need to rethink their lives; Ivan mocks Beiber's singing voice; Billy, later in his post, tells Jesse to "go back to 8th grade to learn your amendments". Karen Chavez, in a post I have not quoted above, claims that "if you say you hate him and that his voice sounds like a girl,you know that you secretely like him and secretely listen to his music".

You know what? I don't give a damn about Justin Beiber. He's a singer, and some people like him, and that's fine for them. Some people don't like him, and that's fine for them too. I'm sick of everyone trying to force their opinions on everyone else. Why can't we just let people have their own preferences? Is a little tolerance really too much to ask?

Stop arguing about Justin Beiber. It doesn't matter. No matter how essential you believe it is that everyone in the whole damn world be in love with Beiber, or that everyone hate him, it still doesn't matter. So give it a rest, because we're tired of hearing it.

Friday, October 29, 2010

A Reflection

    As you may have guessed, considering that this itself is on my blog, this year’s English assignments have been submitted through said blog. Originally I had intended to write random posts as topics came to mind, interspersed with a few of my collected story beginnings, but throughout the first quarter the majority of my posts have been “Unfinished Writing”. I think this is because I have recently had a continuous stream of ideas. In looking over my blog posts, I have found interesting variations in the inspiration for these beginnings, as well as a very different tone from the highly structured essays I have also written.
    My story beginnings are not, as you may expect, inspired by any mysterious and deep part of my soul. I doubt many writers really have one of those. The ideas for most of them came out of nowhere, a thought I had at lunch, or something I read recently, perhaps. Sometimes they originate from characters, which in turn may spring from anywhere. But I think the most common origin is simply when I hear or think of a phrase that intrigues me. Take, for example, The Time of the Plus:
The Time of the Plus: The time in Metronium when all the clocks stop, new buildings suddenly appear where none were before, the Sternix reappear, and the Plus herself comes into power. Once well-known among Metronians, this legend has faded from the minds of all but a few.
This story began when my father said something about “The time of the plus is here”, although I no longer remember the exact phrasing. I do know that there was never any specific meaning to it, and so I began to wonder: What if the Plus were a very powerful person? What if the Time of the Plus were the time in which that person becomes even more powerful? Maybe the Plus is a legend, and maybe there could be clocks in it… So you see, my stories are often just embellishments of other people’s interesting turn of phrase.
    Then there are the stories that begin with a character. The prime example of this is Malt, the novel-in-progress, an excerpt of which I posted on my blog. An excerpt of an excerpt, if you will:
Who was Maxwell Malt?
Oh, everyone had heard of him, of course. You weren’t much of anybody in Eastport if you’d never heard of Maxwell Malt. Some called him a magician, others the superhero of the day, and still others the “people’s hero”, whatever that meant. He had done amazing things. He had saved the city and its surrounding area from bizarre villains countless times, including, once, an army of giant animate teddy bears. Everyone knew it. Most people had witnessed his heroism firsthand. And yet the question still circulated the streets daily.
Who was Maxwell Malt?
Malt is, essentially, about Max and the resolution of some of his identity issues; the story is driven entirely by the character, because he is so vivid in my mind. Maxwell Malt appeared in his entirety in a very strange dream I had involving, yes, an army of giant animate teddy bears. The character was so complete from his first appearance that I knew he had a story in need of telling. To get there, I combined the mysterious air that surrounds everything in dreams with the fact that most superheroes have a secret identity, and this strangeness was the result.
    One of the reasons I feel comfortable posting my weird stories on my blog is that it’s an easily moderated medium. I am often afraid to show my writing to people because I worry that it isn’t any good, and no one likes to be criticized. On a blog, however, all anyone can do is post a comment, and those comments I find offensive or don’t care for can be deleted quite easily. So far I haven’t had to do this, which helps to improve my opinion of this whole blogging thing. Without the blog, I might never have exposed my writing to others, and thus never have gotten feedback of any kind (though, admittedly, my current comments are all from Mr Sutherland). Those comments that have been posted have improved my own opinion of my writing, which is always a good thing in my opinion.
    There is one very big difference between the blog post assignments and other, more structured papers I have written: assignments submitted through the blog are looser. Without a rigid structure, it is easier for a writer’s voice to get through, and people are more comfortable saying what they think. My one truly aimless post is a testament to this:
I think about a lot of weird things in my spare time. I swear this isn't my fault; when my mind is allowed to wander, it comes back with the strangest ideas. But one that I have continuously analyzed and wondered about is this: Is reality defined by a person's perception of it?
If I were to write a structured essay about my tendencies toward existential crisis, it would sound much less like I do when engaged in conversation, and that would make it more difficult for me to get my point across. In fact, in a structured essay I might not choose this subject at all, because of the possible problems with being understood. Also (and I in no way speak for everyone), when writing along very specific guidelines, I tend to come across as excessively stiff and formal. Usually my writing style mirrors the way I speak, and it sounds much more natural. Perhaps this is an improvement, perhaps not.
    As for my goals for my future writing, I need to get better about revising things. My “official” method of writing is stream-of-consciousness scribbling or typing, later to be gone over and all its badly-written parts cut out. Or, at least, I intend to go over it. I often forget about revision and put my first-draft story up on my blog for the world to see. Afterward, of course, I reread it and find it to be severely lacking in some area or other. For example, the first two paragraphs of this story:
There were hundreds of different clans and provinces and other self-governing colonies of dragons in Attria, some of which were constantly at war or just disagreement; others pretended that certain colonies didn’t exist for the sake of peace. Dragons are not, by nature, cooperative with those unlike them, resulting in a tangle of boundary lines to confuse even the most accomplished of cartographers. The colonies were not receptive to new dragons emigrating from other colonies, and their leaders rarely had any kind of meeting because of the everlasting tensions between them.
But Draigfest was different. Draigfest happened in the very center of the valley, where no colony claimed territory, and it was a festival, or possibly a convention, for those dragons that weren’t really concerned one way or another with the misdeeds of their neighbours’ ancestors and were curious about the other colonies. Some, over the years, had even built up long-distance friendships with other dragons.
I believe there are all of three pronouns between those two paragraphs. This is a result of not revising the story; had I done so, I would have realised that the word “dragon” is repeated a tedious number of times. This sort of thing happens far more often than I would like. If I could get better about revision, my writing would definitely improve and no one would have to read the gibberish my mind spews on autopilot. And speaking of revision, reviews from others would probably also be quite helpful; I know of several people who will give me honest criticism and whose suggestions have improved my work in the past. After all, every decent writer needs an editor—and I hope to be more than merely decent.

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

Of Mice and Men

    Conflict is one of those things required to make a book readable; no one wants to read about characters for whom everything always goes perfectly. There will always be a central conflict, though it may be difficult to determine, as in John Steinbeck’s novella Of Mice and Men. This book outlines the story of two migrant workers by the names of George and Lennie. One of the main issues we see, although there are many, is that Lennie has a child’s mind despite his considerable size. He seems not to know his own strength, which results in the accidental killing of creatures such as mice. This, along with the conflicts detailed below, contributes to the novella’s central conflict, the constant battle between the two migrant workers and society.
    Our first demonstration of this conflict is very near the beginning, when George and Lennie are discussing their future. They are, at the time, on their way to another in what appears to be a series of ranches, where they intend to work. George decides that they will stop for the night because they still have some distance to go--the fault, apparently, of a dishonest bus driver--and after a certain point Lennie brings up their plans for the money they will earn. From what George says, the reader understands that they intend to raise enough money to buy their own small farm so that they will no longer have to work for someone else. His explanation begins with a description of others who live the way he and Lennie do:
“‘Guys like us, that work on ranches, are the loneliest guys in the world. They got no family. They don’t belong no place. They come to a ranch an’ work up a stake and then they go inta town and blow their stake, and the first thing you know they’re poundin’ their tail on some other ranch. They ain’t got nothing to look ahead to.’” (13)
George continues from this with an explanation of why he and Lennie are not like them and how they will eventually have the aforementioned small farm. The message is clear: society both demands and expects that they will give up on this dream of theirs, just like everybody else who works as they do. Their intention is to break this apparently long-standing mold and actually manage to achieve the future they want. This may not appear to be an actual conflict, because it is simply George stating what he believes to be true, but in fact it is more than that: it is an internal struggle against people’s expectations. The same conflict is displayed much later on as well, when Lennie presents their dream to the stable buck, Crooks, who doesn’t believe that they will ever actually manage it any more than anyone else has:
“‘They come, an’ they quit an’ go on; an’ every damn one of ‘em’s got a little piece of land in his head. An’ never a God damn one of ‘em ever gets it...They’re all the time talkin’ about it, but it’s jus’ in their head.” (74)
This brings up the interesting question of the reason none of them ever attain their desire. Perhaps it is that society forces them to. It is assumed that they will fail, and no matter how hard they try, they cannot help but live up to this depressing expectation--which goes on to reinforce the idea that none of them will ever succeed. George and Lennie, however, actually manage to convince some of the naysayers through the strength of their conviction that they will be different--although this doesn’t last forever.
   At the beginning of the novel, it is mentioned that something happened in the town of Weed which caused George and Lennie to lose their jobs; this seems to have been caused by Lennie, although it is not originally mentioned how. After what seems to be about a day working on the new ranch, George elaborates on this occurrence to Slim, whose position is identified as “jerkline skinner” and who wants to know more:
“‘He seen this girl in a red dress. Dumb bastard like he is, he wants to touch ever’thing he likes. Just wants to feel it. So he reaches out to feel this red dress an’ the girl lets out a squawk, and that gets Lennie all mixed up, and he holds on ‘cause that’s the only thing he can think to do. Well, this girl squawks and squawks...That girl rabbits an’ tell the law she been raped. The guys in Weed start a party out to lynch Lennie.’” (41-42)
This time it is Lennie who is up against society; the majority of people do not understand the way his mind works. He, with his inability to understand the implications of his action, attempts to touch the girl’s red dress just because he likes it, without any sinister motive. The girl assumes that he, probably like many other men, is making unsolicited and unwanted advances, and reacts as if this expectation is a concrete fact. The men of Weed take this girl at her word, because it is likely that they know her and don’t know Lennie, and certainly don’t understand Lennie or his mental difficulties. Based on this disconnect, they decide to take their revenge and lynch Lennie. It is clear that they do not succeed in this attempt, because Lennie is very much alive when the story takes place, but the fact that he might have been lynched serves as another example of the ways that society is fighting him, and George by association.
   Now we come to the end, the final manifestation of their struggle. The trouble begins when the rather...dishonest wife of Curley (the boss’s son) goes into the barn to talk to Lennie. He begins to talk about how he likes “to pet nice things with [his] fingers”, and Curley’s nameless wife responds by offering her hair as something for him to pet. After a few moments she tells him to stop, which confuses him--much like the events in Weed--and causes him to hold on. She screams, he tries to stop her and ends up accidentally killing her. When she is discovered, both George and Slim understand that Lennie didn’t do it on purpose, but Curley flies into a rage and will not listen to reason. Another worker on the ranch, Carlson, is in agreement with Curley, and finding that Lennie has taken his gun, is even more livid. The two of them, accompanied by Slim and George, set out to hunt Lennie down and make him pay for his mistake. George, however, splits from the rest of the group and goes to where he knows Lennie will be. He talks to Lennie about the dream that he now knows will never be, and then he shoots Lennie in the back of the head to prevent him from suffering. He does this because he knows that Curley would make Lennie suffer if he were allowed to catch up with him. This is demonstrated by an earlier statement of Curley’s:
“‘That big son-of-a-bitch done it. I know he done it...I’m gonna get him. I’m going for my shotgun. I’ll kill the big son-of-a-bitch myself. I’ll shoot ‘im in the guts.” (96)
To Curley, it doesn’t matter that Lennie doesn’t know his own strength, or that killing Curley’s wife was an accident. He refuses to believe that it could have been an accident because he already dislikes Lennie for other reasons, and because he cannot accept that others think differently than he does. In a way, Curley might be representative of society; he does everything within his power to control his wife, he antagonizes Lennie because Lennie is different from him, and he doesn’t bother to think about whether Lennie’s actions might have been accidental before deciding that he deserves to suffer. It follows, then, that the boss’s son is the embodiment of all George and Lennie were trying to fight.
   As demonstrated above, George and Lennie are engaged in a continuous conflict with the pressures of society, which control their lives up to and including the time of Lennie’s death. This could be said to mirror our lives today, even though we have long since escaped the Great Depression; more so now than ever, society demands that we conform to a certain mold, and as in Of Mice and Men, anyone not following expectations will find themselves ostracized. George and Lennie’s doomed attempt to attain their dream is an example of an attempt to break the mold, and it raises the worrying question: are all such attempts destined to fail?